Friday, 19 February 2010

Nature or Nurture

I have clever children, there I have said it.  I have got rid of the elephant in the room.  They are very bright and intelligent (gifted and talented they call them at school, but that term just doesn't sit well with me, as all children are talented in someway).  But before I go on about their amazing abilities, let me tell you a story:



I use to feel inferior as a mum, both the boys were late walkers and never even crawled.  I used to compare maxi to his peers in my NCT antenatal group when we lived in Berkshire.  I used to come home and cry and feel inferior as he wasn't meeting his milestones as the other children were.  I was a bad mummy, I didn't "do" tummy time or structured play activities.  I would much rather enjoy a baby massage with him or sing and dance.  I didn't have the right parenting books, I was not allowing him to be the best he could.

Then things got much worse, Maxi became unwell and I became pregnant and the thought of going to signing tots or music with mummy, just didn't appeal to me anymore, so we played at home, I took him swimming once a week at least and we would go to a little music group which had only just started up down the road.  We looked at moving back to the North East so that I didn't have to go back to work.
All the other children in the group were walking, eating well and sleeping.  I couldn't compete.  Maxi eventually walked at 15 months 2 days before mini was born.


When mini was born, we went out for lots of walks and played in the park, I continued to take both the boys swimming at least once a week and we sang lots of songs and always chatted during the day.  We had fun.  I didn't worry about tummy time with mini, I didn't feel I had to do things any other way that our way.  I was free of the competitive nature of mothers with children the same age, as I never went to an antenatal class I didn't have anyone to compare him too.  So when he didn't walk till 17 months old I wasn't worried and when he started mimicking words at 7 months old I thought nothing of it.

I just loved the boys and wanted them to be happy.  Fast forward to last weeks parents evening.  


Both boys are exceptionally clever it seems, Mini can read, count to over 100, do single figure additions and has a passion for music.  He sometimes struggles with his new found temper, but he is amazing.  He makes friends really easily and chatters away to all and sundry with great inter-personal skills.
Maxi is whizzing ahead.  He is doing mathematics from year 2 and will be moving on to year 3 after half term.  He can do multiplication, understands and works in thousands, hundreds, tens and units.  He loves helping the other children with their math work, explaining it to them in an easily understandable way.

He is top of the class for phonics and writing.  His investigative skills are growing day by day and he has a love and understanding of basic science principals way above his years.

But even though he has all this ability, he is not smug, in fact he is the opposite he revels in his friends getting star of the day or one off awards, he doesn't crave recognition in any way at school and is a joy to teach.

He is kind and considerate and as much at home playing tig and starwars in the playground as he is in a small group telling a story.  He is 5 in March.  He is amazing and fills me with joy and fear in equal measure.

The question I am always asked is what am I doing to help the boys, what work do I do with them, as they don't want their children to miss out.

But the thing is, I have never hot housed the boys, we don't do flash cards or sums and exercises at home.  I don't make them read to me if they don't want to.  I don't force them to do homework.  I have never made them recite numbers or the alphabet to me.

But, we do have magnetic numbers and letters on the fridge, we sing songs, we make things, we talk all the time, our books are all on display and within easy reach, we visit the library, we still go swimming, we laugh, dance, create, we go on the PC, spend time on the wii, live and love.



I am not a great believer in after-school activities, both boys come home and the first thing after a snack is play outside, go to the park or go out on their scooters.  I don't feel the need to limit screen time, our only rule there is that there is none after 6pm and both boys have a leapster.

So the thing is they are just the way they are, the thirst for knowledge may not continue and I don't mind that (well I don't think I will, only time will tell).  They may just start to balance with all the children in their classes as they get older.  They may get distracted by other activities.  But this is fine, ultimately all I still want for them is to be happy.

So is it nature of nurture their cleverness, well MadDad is clever too, he did his exams etc a year earlier, but I am just kind of average.  In my opinion what good is intelligence if you don't have the ambition to match.  Also I quite like being average, It has never held me back.  I did well at work, excelled in fact.  If I set my mind to something, then I tend to find a way to achieve it.

I just don't know, but we are all happy and we are all healthy so we will be going on as we have been and taking each day as it comes, with lots of loving and firm family values.

But you know what the things that thrilled me most were hearing about how well they are behaved, that they have good interpersonal skills and are both joys to teach.  This wasn't just by their own teachers, but other people came up to us in the course of the evening and told us that we should be proud of our boys and you know what, we are.  We have been unable to wipe the smiles of our faces.



Share/Save/Bookmark

Comments (32)

Loading... Logging you in...
  • Logged in as
Fabulous. No wonder you are proud of them, in fact, I think I am a little proud of them too! They sound so full of fun and life, so enthusiastic about learning and discovering things.

And you know what? I think you sell yourself short by describing yourself as 'average'. You are not an 'average' mother - your amazing, well-rounded, happy, confident boys are testament to that.

x
1 reply · active 788 weeks ago
What a lovely lovely post. You have given your boys what every child thrives on - oceans and oceans of your time, patience and love. You have every right to feel proud.
1 reply · active less than 1 minute ago
what a wonderful post. And i love your summation at the end, yes cleverness is nice but to know that people enjoy being around them must be the most wonderful thing of all. they sound like two well grounded and great little lads. you must be so proud of them
1 reply · active 788 weeks ago
There is nothing wrong with being proud of your kids.
My hubby is not big on going out. It's an achievement for him to take the little one to the garden! We tried playgroups but they didn't really work. So my little one doesn't get out much during the week. But she reads books, draws, plays piano, and generally has a good time. I worry about her social skills (probably unnecessarily because she loves people and is very friendly) but otherwise her development seems absolutely fine. This post gives me hope! Thankyou.
1 reply · active 788 weeks ago
Wonderful ! sounds perfect .to me ... never had a parenting book - went on instinct. Don't drive so couldn't do a lot of ativities but we walked & talked ! Neither crawled ( most dyslexics don't )

Be proud you deserve it xx
1 reply · active 788 weeks ago
Like Penny said - the talking to them is the best thing a parent can do - even when they are tiny & you are just talking to them whilst you are doing stuff round the house.

I don't drive either so we walked everywhere during the week & talked about what we saw - the colours of cars, the numbers on the doors & the changes in the seasons.

Your boys sound great & seeing the pics they are dead cute too.

Long may it continue - it gets harder being a bright boy the older you get (I know from my 2's experience) but it is possible to rise about the silly comments and succeed.
1 reply · active 788 weeks ago
I'm not surprised to hear that your boys are so wonderful - you're their mum!

Lovely photos of them too. Sounds like you're doing a great job!
1 reply · active 788 weeks ago
Oh that gives me goose bumps! You are too right to be proud of them!
I think we have the same concepts of education as you have. No I don't have the flash cards either, or tons of educational books, etc. I don't spend my days trying to improve their abilities to develop.
I simply grasp any opportunity to highlight things as we go along, it can be trying to recognise numbers, counting snails on the way to school or making up songs. They do watch TV and I don't lose sleep over it.
Your boys seem to be very happy and balanced so you are definitely doing something good :)
1 reply · active 788 weeks ago
Hooray for a relaxed, rounded and stimulating childhood. No flash cards but lots of play, play, play. I'd be very happy growing up in your home.
1 reply · active 788 weeks ago
I think that all the lovely things that we see that you do with your boys are turning them into well rounded, kind, interested and educated ( in the ways of language, reading , speech , etc., as your activities touch all of those) little people. I think some of nature comes into it too. My children, being adopted and coming from taotally different backgrounds, are each very definitely showing the nature side! They of course have the qualities of my nurture, but they all now are very much taking after their natural parents in all kinds of ways! As for flash card... why do they need them, you are teaching them all they need to know - naturally! suzie. xxx
What a lovely post - I think it's lovely that you are proud of their achievements, and so you should be. We also had the magnetic alphabet on the fridge and my little one loved it.
1 reply · active 788 weeks ago
Well done! You're right to be proud. My mother used to say "You can be as smart as you want, but it'll do you no good without manners." Smart is great. Well rounded with good interpersonal skills? That's gold dust!
1 reply · active 788 weeks ago
That's just great! I love that sometimes it's best to be just yourself. Star of the day certainly belongs to you today :)
1 reply · active 788 weeks ago
Its interesting that your kids are both like that. My eldest is a summer born (August birthday) boy and sounds like your kids with his reading. He learned to read so quickly and was always reading way ahead of his peers. He is 9 now and has a reading age of over 12, he devours books and is always reading. My middle child (a girl) is now nearly 7 and is still really struggling with reading, she is at the level my son was at in reception and is she almost at the end of year two now. I have found it very hard not to compare them. We were like you, we didn't do much at home in terms of keyword flashcards or any of that. However, we are a the point now where we feel that perhaps it is our fault in some way our daughter is struggling so much. I can tell from her vocabulary and her observations on life etc that she is bright, but she finds it all such a struggle. On the postive side she is so popular, friendly and easy going, she gets so many play date & party invitations etc, and she is a happy, well adjusted friendly child so I really feel that that is much more important in a way. I just don't want her self esteem to be knocked.
2 replies · active 788 weeks ago
I, like you, think that children should be children and allowed time to play and express themselves, not have their lives over timetabled with out of school activities etc. You sound like you are doing a grand job and your boys sound a delight. Be justly proud :)

Sorry for the overly long comment, I had to split it in two!
You know what, knowing you all, this doesn't surprise me a bit. There is so much more to parenting than flash cards, and milestone monitoring, and you two have always had it spot on in my mind. I was planning a post on this very subject for today so I won't go on, other than to say please don't ever describe yourself as average. You are far, far from average x
Your boys both sound amazing! I am with you on the structured activity front. When the Bear was first born I went mad going to all sorts of classes and meet ups that he was too young to care about and when I really should have been chilling the hell out and trying to settle into being a mum. Soon after I gave up on all that sort of caper and we were both a lot happier for it. Now we go to one class a week - a Gymboree music class that he adores - and the rest of the time we go for long walks or to the park or the City farm, or we sit at home and read books, or do the washing together or whatever else we feel like doing that day. It suits us down to the ground, and while he's not talking yet I don't think I can blame that on a lack of a structured activity timetable. Each to their own though - I know people who have taken their children to classes five days a week since they were babies and they love it. Me, I prefer to be able to sit about till midday in my pyjamas if need be.
They sound quite brilliant! Nothing to be embarrased about, especially on your own blog, brag away! Don't sell yourself short either, you write so well, school smarts are not the only metric of measuring. I'm a little the opposite of you, my kids are bright, but I expect them to be. I was an early talker and reader and my parents still think I am a genius. They find it hard to believe I am actually very average among my peers in the world of research!

Post a new comment

Comments by

Related Posts with Thumbnails